An expiry date is more than a date printed on food packaging. It communicates how long a product is expected to remain safe or retain its intended quality when stored under the recommended conditions.
For food manufacturers, assigning an appropriate date is an important responsibility. A shelf-life claim that is too long can expose consumers to potential food safety risks, while one that is unnecessarily short can result in avoidable product waste and financial losses.
When expiry dates are not supported by suitable evidence, the consequences can affect consumers, manufacturers, retailers and the wider food supply chain.
The Risks of Incorrect Food Expiry Dates
Incorrect shelf-life claims can create problems beyond the product itself. They can affect a manufacturer’s ability to meet customer expectations, maintain regulatory compliance and protect its reputation.
There are two important scenarios to consider.
1. Shelf-Life Claims That Are Too Long
A product assigned a shelf life beyond its demonstrated suitability may remain available for sale after it has deteriorated or no longer meets the relevant safety and quality requirements.
Depending on the product, storage conditions and potential hazards, this may result in:
- Microbiological deterioration or unacceptable microbial levels.
- Changes in taste, smell, texture, colour or appearance.
- Reduced product quality before the declared date.
- Consumer complaints and potential food safety incidents.
- Product withdrawals or recalls.
- Increased exposure to regulatory and legal consequences.
A product that appears normal does not necessarily meet all its microbiological safety requirements. Similarly, a product that has passed its date marking is not automatically contaminated; the significance of the date depends on the type of date declared and the applicable requirements.
The important consideration is whether the manufacturer’s shelf-life claim is supported by appropriate evidence for that particular product.
2. Shelf-Life Claims That Are Too Short
Assigning a shelf life that is more conservative than necessary can also affect a food business.
Products may be discarded or removed from sale while they could still meet their intended quality and safety requirements under the specified storage conditions.
This can contribute to:
- Unnecessary food waste.
- Increased product returns and disposal costs.
- Reduced profitability.
- Shorter distribution and retail selling windows.
- Challenges with stock rotation and inventory management.
- Lost commercial opportunities.
A suitable shelf-life claim should therefore be evidence-based. It should not be extended without justification, but it should also not be unnecessarily restrictive.
What Can Cause an Incorrect Shelf-Life Claim?
A shelf-life claim can become unreliable when important product or production factors are overlooked.
Several factors can influence whether a food product remains suitable throughout its intended shelf life.
Changes to Product Formulation
Changes to ingredients, preservatives, moisture content, acidity or other formulation characteristics may influence product stability and microbial behaviour.
A shelf-life claim established for an earlier formulation should not automatically be applied to a reformulated product without considering whether the changes affect its expected performance.
Changes to Manufacturing Processes
Adjustments to processing conditions, equipment, production practices or hygiene controls can influence the characteristics of the finished product.
Even where a product name and formulation remain unchanged, significant production changes may justify reviewing whether the existing shelf-life claim remains appropriate.
Packaging Changes
Packaging plays an important role in protecting food products from external influences.
Changes to packaging materials, seals, closures or packaging formats may affect factors such as moisture transfer, oxygen exposure and product protection. These changes can influence how a product behaves during storage.
Storage and Distribution Conditions
A shelf-life claim is linked to the storage conditions under which the product is expected to be kept.
Temperature fluctuations, inadequate refrigeration, unsuitable storage conditions and interruptions in the cold chain can affect product quality and safety.
Manufacturers should ensure that the storage instructions communicated to customers are realistic and supported by the conditions considered when establishing the product’s shelf life.
When Should Food Manufacturers Review Their Shelf-Life Claims?
A shelf-life claim should not be treated as permanent simply because it has been used successfully in the past.
Manufacturers should consider reviewing existing claims when significant changes occur or when new information suggests that the original claim may no longer be appropriate.
Examples include:
- Introducing a new product or product variation.
- Changing an ingredient, recipe or formulation.
- Modifying manufacturing or processing conditions.
- Changing packaging materials or packaging formats.
- Introducing a new storage or distribution arrangement.
- Receiving repeated complaints about premature spoilage.
- Identifying unexpected product deterioration.
- Considering an extension to an existing shelf-life period.
- Reviewing product specifications or customer requirements.
A review helps determine whether the available evidence still supports the declared shelf life or whether further assessment is necessary.
Why Evidence Matters When Assigning Expiry Dates
Manufacturers should be able to explain the basis for the shelf-life period assigned to their products.
Relying only on experience, assumptions or the shelf life of a similar product may not provide sufficient evidence. Products with different formulations, processing conditions and packaging characteristics can behave differently over time.
Appropriate shelf-life assessment provides information that can help manufacturers make informed decisions about product suitability and the period for which a product is expected to meet its defined requirements.
The type and extent of assessment should be appropriate to the product, its intended storage conditions and the risks being evaluated.
Keeping supporting documentation is also important. It helps manufacturers demonstrate how shelf-life decisions were reached and provides a reference point when products, processes or specifications change.
Food Labelling and Shelf-Life Responsibilities
Food date marking is an important part of communicating product information to consumers.
Manufacturers must consider the applicable food labelling requirements when deciding which date marking is appropriate for their products. The distinction between a best-before date and a use-by or expiry date is particularly important, as these terms do not communicate exactly the same thing.
South African food businesses should refer to the applicable food labelling legislation and relevant guidance when determining their date-marking responsibilities.
An appropriate shelf-life claim should be consistent with the product’s characteristics, intended storage conditions and supporting evidence. Correct labelling is not simply an administrative exercise; it forms part of responsible product management and consumer protection.
Protect Your Products, Consumers and Brand
An inaccurate shelf-life claim can have consequences long after a product has left the manufacturing facility. Product withdrawals, customer complaints, wasted stock and damage to brand reputation can all place additional pressure on a food business.
Taking a proactive approach to shelf-life management helps manufacturers identify when existing claims need to be reviewed and when further scientific assessment may be necessary.
Envirocare Laboratory supports food manufacturers with science-based shelf-life validation and microbiological testing, providing relevant analytical information to assist with informed product safety and quality decisions.
Whether you are developing a new product, reviewing an existing shelf-life claim or investigating premature product deterioration, appropriate laboratory assessment can form an important part of your decision-making process.
Envirocare Laboratory – Your Partner in Compliance Success.
Contact Envirocare Laboratory
Potchefstroom Laboratory
6 Du Plooy Street, Potchefstroom, 2531
Telephone: +27 18 294 4283
Cell: +27 71 353 5740
Email: info@envirocarelab.co.za
Western Cape Laboratory
PTF 18, Three Fountains Estate, R304, Philadelphia, Western Cape, 7304
Telephone: +27 82 343 9579 | +27 81 834 7198
Email: info_westerncape@envirocarelab.co.za
Website: https://envirocarelab.co.za/
References
- Department of Health, South Africa. (2023). Food Labelling Guidelines. Pretoria: Department of Health.
- Codex Alimentarius Commission. (2018). General Standard for the Labelling of Prepackaged Foods (CXS 1-1985): Date Marking. Rome: FAO/WHO.
- World Health Organization (WHO). (2022). Food Safety. Geneva: WHO.

